As many people are aware I’ve used Fedora for quite a long time… and with the release of the first ALPHA of Fedora 15 I got this tiny itch to check out GNOME3, namely, the gnome-shell.
I’ve have to say that the first impressions I had from GNOME Shell from Fedora 13 raised in me a high level of skepticism towards the new interface of GNOME Shell. The contents of this text are mainly influenced by my own view of the things… I don’t mean to be disruptive… but some things need to be said…
#1 – For starters… gnome-shell UI doesn’t seem to lag that much anymore… this is a very positive step, as lagging interfaces really kill my joy!
#2 – The sound applet – Looks interesting, very well copied from Ubuntu’s Sound Menu, at least in concept. Now this must be a slap in the face for some people I knew that threw a couple of harsh critics on Canonical. Well done to whoever made it that way… you have empowered Canonical’s design and now I will probably watch a full legion of Ubuntu fanboys bragging about how GNOME copied their Sound Menu. /* taking cover */
#3 – The configuration screen – Interesting stuff… But also Deja Vu… I think all the nice people migrating from KDE will find themselves at home with this new ‘control center’. The resemblances are quite awesome!
#4 – The user applet, which I don’t what to call it… Yet shows a lot of resemblances with Canonical’s Me Menu. At least some functions are there, but what I really find strange is the absence of ‘Restart’ button. I guess it’s now really an issue to tap ALT+F2 and issue a ‘shutdown now -frn’ or ‘init 6’ command, I just hope the system allows it.
#5 – The language applet – Interesting thing, but once again I have this Canonical Deja Vu feeling… Not again…
#6 – Moving the cursor to upper left triggers pretty much an effect which brings me a Deja Vu style from Compiz Wall Expo plugins. Awesome stuff!
#7 – The fonts are awesome, my heart is now broken… I don’t really need to install Ubuntu Fonts.
#8 – Icons seem to be monochrome! Awesome, but yet I have this deja vu feeling!
#9 – Artwork – My heart is broken (probably my cóccix as well, I’ve felt from the chair).
#10 – ALT+F2 – Awesome, this is really something I’m used too, I feel at home! I don’t really need menus at all once I know all the commands I need from the top of my head.
#11 – The number of clicks I need to perform to reach for example, Google Chrome. Yeah, ALT+F2 is way faster.
#12 – The default theme… to be replaced by Sonar (has anyone done the GTK3 port?, please someone do it fast, before I loose my motivation).
#13 – System Load up – awesome, nothing to state….
#14 – Calendar ‘applet’ – cool stuff, but evolution is crashing on me (keep in mind this is Alpha, so no real deal here, I’m sure it will be fixed);
…
Ok the list could be very long to make this shorter… Despite of all, I’m really waiting to see the final version of gnome-shell… I don’t find it much of innovation, as much of the features seem to be taken from other popular software. Everything worked out fine (except evolution) out of the box… I’m actually happy to see that some Fedora fundamentalists after throwing such a heavy load into Canonical, they ended up by handing over something that in much resembles to some software available from Canonical. I’m sure their hearts will be broken… many of this features were considered ‘kinky’ by them and oriented to Fan Boys… I wonder why they choosed to follow the same path, clearly aiming for those that they choosed to combat? Hmmz… I sense some hipocrisy here.
But I’ve gotta be honest, much of this ‘innovations’ actually gave me a rush to see the final product and to run it for a longer period. While many people from the Fedora circle violently attack gnome-shell, I can smell here potential to be a success, I only fear for the quality of the artwork here, which neither presents a nice visual desktop metaphor, neither even looks attractive to me… but once more, I believe it will be fully customizable. Another I missed was the normal system-* applets to configure several parts of the system… I’m happy that openSUSE will not forget YaST for GNOME3, thus I won’t feel defrauded when I run GNOME3 on openSUSE due to missing configuration applications.
My final veredict… this 9 months waiting for GNOME3 on openSUSE are going to be painful, because now that I’ve tasted the forbiden God’s honey, I want MORE! And for real… for everyone out there speaking bad about gnome-shell, please guys, be mindful of one thing… though this will require a bit of love for people to get used to, some of the features presented are actually nice. For those who love GNOME, but don’t really like the shell… Are you aware that you can manage your sessions on gnome-session? I’m not sure, but I think most of that functionality was actually developed in-house by Novell 😉 and I’m sure it will be explored by a few, while I expect the vast majority of the Hordes will end up by loving this shell…
You shouldn’t really take me serious, but thanks for reading until the end… Now that I know that most people are already wanting to crucify me, I hope that you can take 1 week of your time to test the shell and prove I’m wrong. Maybe then, you will become converts, and I’m will for sure rest my head knowing it was worth to write this text.
NM
DISCLAIMER: For everyone who readed this and as pointed bellow by Adam, it seems that in fact was Ubuntu who copied some aspects of the shell. I don’t really have time to dig up the stuff. I’ve funded my stuff based on what I saw, and Ubuntu released first, apparently based on gnome-shell design. I apologize for being misleading.
Both comments and pings are currently closed.
(…) still looking for a way to reboot my system at the distance of a click :/
I’d say we’re very much on the same page here, Nelson! GNOME Shell has great potential (although it still needs work in some area’s). And I like it…
By the way, I’ve seen the video you flagged on Facebook, installing openSUSE in less than 10 mins… I did it on my normal hardware with a USB2/3 stick (GNOME Live CD 11.4).
Awesome stuff, it’s really fast… I’ve made a small post about it on my forgotten blog (http://nmarques.digitalwhores.net).
This should be advertised by openSUSE Marketing, as it’s a simple procedure with very cool results…
Nelson I believe there are plans to master an openSUSE 11.4 based image with gnome 3.0 built into it
I know, I’ve loaded fcrozat’s spin first, and I have to say that aside from a small glitch on the ATI driver, fcrozat’s spin offers a bit more 😉 People who might try both will know what I mean… though there’s a heads up, Fedora ALPHA is very fast loading and shutting down, damn impressive.
For those who remember David Lynch’s Dune, there’s a small quote I would love to use as a metaphor: “I start to like this Duke” > “I start to like this gnome-shell” 😉
I think GNOME3 is gonna be a killer, but nevertheless, I was expecting better artwork… I hope the final release improves it…
I’m tempted to buy a couple whips and check if our GNOME monkeys work faster with some whip engineering/motivation 😉
I Like Gnome And OpenSuse. But I more like Gnome 2 than 3. More simple and fast.
You might want to go and check the GNOME 3 design documents for the things you assume were copied from Unity, and see which designs actually came first.
Disclaimer added. Thanks for the correction. I’ve seen ‘those’ features first in Ubuntu. My humble apologies.
I’ve been trying Gnome-shell for a while on Fedora 15. Honestly, I like it, but I’m not totally convinced. First of all, when you boot your desktop you find yourself with an useless background, and you must go to “Activities” before you can do anything. I would love to see a “Desktop” tab near “Activities”, in order to place all my shortcuts there (and a few files I want to access quickly).
Without something like that, I feel like I am loosing functionality here. In my case, I’ve been using KDE 4 since 4.4 😉
Regards!