Home Home > 2018 > 07
Sign up | Login

Archive for July, 2018

YaST Squad Sprint 58

July 23rd, 2018 by

Squads in the Team

In the previous post we explained the squads idea and said we would tell more in this report. Thus, we should mention that we finally did three squads for this sprint:

  • The Sockets & Services Squad working on supporting systemd sockets properly and other systemd related tasks (all in the YaST context, of course).
  • The Qt and UI Squad working on user interface things like adding a new view to the package selection to show packages managed by a service, and also some control center improvements.
  • The Bug Fighting Squad handling bugs that are coming in on a daily basis and in our backlog.

Fixed Issues with Disks Larger than 8EiB

It’s quite unlikely that you have at home a disk storage larger than 8EiB (eight exbibytes, 263). But in enterprise or cloud world it might be possible.

And it turned out that the YaST package manager does not handle such large disks well. At the start you would see this false error message:

The Problems

There are two problems:

  • There definitely is a lot of free space on the disk, the error telling the user the space is running out is simply lying.
  • The disk sizes are displayed as wrong negative values.

It turned out that the problem was caused by using the signed 64-bit integer data type which overflows for values bigger than 8EiB and the number becomes negative.

The Fix

We had to fix several places, each required some different solution.

  • Use unsigned 64-bit integers where possible, that obviously avoids overflow.
  • The numbers from libzypp use KiB units, at some places we need to convert that number to MiB. But first we converted to plain bytes (by multiplying by 1024) and then divide by 1MiB. And this first multiply step might cause overflow. Instead we simply convert KiB to MiB directly by dividing by 1024 without risk of overflow in the middle.
  • Use floating point double data type for converting the values to a human readable text or to percents. The double has wider range and in these cases we do not need exact precision so rounding in floating point operations does not matter.
  • Ignore a negative number in the free space check. At one place the value goes through the YaST component system which uses signed integer and this cannot be easily changed. In that case we consider negative free space as enough for installing any package, more than 8EiB free space should be enough for any packageℱ.

There is still some minor issue with the large numbers. The highest supported unit is TiB so even very big numbers are displayed in TiB units as on the screenshot above. The fix is planned to be released as a maintenance update and this change would break the backward compatibility so we will improve it later but only for the future releases.


But the problem was how to test the behavior? You could fake some numbers in the code but for full testing or QA validation it would be nice to test on a real disk. But you usually do not have such a large storage for testing…

Fortunately in Linux it is possible to fake such large file system quite easily using sparse files and loop devices. Here is a short how to:

# create two big sparse files
truncate -s 6E /tmp/huge_file1
truncate -s 6E /tmp/huge_file2

# create block devices via loopback
losetup -f /tmp/huge_file1
losetup -f /tmp/huge_file2

# get the loop back device names, the names might be different
# if the system already uses some other loop back devices
losetup -a
/dev/loop1: [0056]:1171324 (/tmp/huge_file2)
/dev/loop0: [0056]:1171323 (/tmp/huge_file1)

# create a btrfs file system over both "disks"
mkfs.btrfs -K /dev/loop0 /dev/loop1

# mount it on /mnt2 (or whatever else, do no use /mnt, that is ignored by libzypp!)
mkdir /mnt2
mount /dev/loop0 /mnt2

# verify the size
df -h /mnt2
Filesystem      Size  Used Avail Use% Mounted on
/dev/loop0       12E   17M   12E   1% /mnt2
# voila! you have a 12EiB file system! enjoy 😉

Note: Obviously even if you have a 12EiB filesystem you cannot save there more data than in the real file system below (in /tmp in this case). If you try you will get write errors, there is no prepetuum mobile…

Speeding Up Unit Tests and Travis Builds in yast2-storage-ng

The new yast2-storage-ng package has a quite large set of unit tests. That’s good, it allows to have less buggy code and make sure the features work as expected.

On the other hand the drawback is that running the tests take too much time. If you have to wait for 3 or 4 minutes after any small change in the code then either you waste too much time or you do not run the tests at all. So we looked into speeding up the tests.

Running Tests in Parallel

The main problem was that all tests were executed sequentially one by one. Even if you have a multi CPU system only one processor was used. It turned out that using the parallel_test Ruby gem allows easily running the tests in parallel utilizing all available processors.

The only possible problem is that there must not be any dependencies or conflicts between the tests otherwise running them in parallel would fail. Fortunately there was only one small issue in the yast2-storage-ng tests and we could enable the parallel tests without much work.

Running Travis Jobs in Parallel

Also the Travis job took quite a lot of time. Running the tests in parallel helped a bit at Travis but still was not good enough.

Fortunately Travis allows running multiple jobs in parallel. Therefore we split the single CI job which runs the tests, builds the package, runs syntax check, etc… into three independent groups which can be started in parallel.


If you are interested in details you might check our updated Travis documentation and the Parallel tests documentation. Or check the announcement on the YaST mailing list.


Here are some real numbers to see the speedup:

  • Running the test suite locally (rake test:unit): from 2:44 to 0:38 (4.3x speed up on a quad core CPU with hyper-threading enabled)
  • Building the package locally (rake osc:build): from 137s to 49s (with cached RPM packages but includes chroot installation)
  • Package build in OBS: from 323s-505s to 102s-235s (it highly depends on the speed of the used worker)
  • Travis speed up: from 8-10 minutes to 3-4minutes (using both parallel Travis jobs and parallel tests)

This allows us to continue with adding even more tests into the package. :smiley:

What Packages are Provided by a Product Extension/Module?

In the Software Management module we have a Repositories view where you can see the packages grouped by the repository that provides them. But this is not really helpful if you want to see what is delivered with a product Extension or Module, because each product module is composed of several repositories: the originally released packages, the updates, the sources, the debuginfos.

Fortunately, the repositories for each product module are grouped together in a repository Service, and we have added a Services filter to Software Management.

Qt Service filter:

ncurses Service filter:

(Reference: https://fate.suse.com/320573)

Update on YaST Development Status

July 5th, 2018 by

Five weeks without blogging is certainly a quite an hiatus for the YaST Team. But fear no more, we are back! This is the first time in quite a while in which our post is not titled “Highlights of YaST Development Sprint” and there are good reasons for that.

Adapting the YaST Team Structure the Agile Way

Now that openSUSE Leap 15.0 is out and SUSE Enterprise Linux 15 is ready to be shipped, we felt it was time to rethink our activities. For the duration of the storage-ng development, we had split the YaST team into two sub-teams: Team S for Storage and Team R for the Rest. But now new challenges await us; there are some things that were pushed aside because getting storage-ng into an acceptable state had top priority.

We decided we’d try an approach that other development teams in SUSE have already been using successfully: split up the YaST team into “squads” of 3-5 people each for the duration of a couple of sprints. Each squad is centered around a big topic that needs to be addressed. There is no long-term fixed assignment of anyone to any squad; the idea is to shuffle people and thus know-how around as needed, of course taking each developer’s interests into account. So the squads and the topics will change every few weeks.

Is this the pure spirit of Scrum and the agile bible? We don’t know. And we don’t care. The agile spirit is to adapt your work based on what makes sense in every moment. We work the agile way, so the way of working also has to be agile.

The next sprint’s report will contain more information about the first set of squads and the results they are delivering. But meanwhile we have done much more than just reorganizing our forces. While the sprint-based work was suspended (thus the blog title not containing the word “sprint”), the YaST team still managed to put out of the door quite some features, improvements and bug fixes targeting mainly Tumbleweed.

Expert Partitioner: Moving Partitions

After quite some effort, the YaST team has completely rewritten the Expert Partitioner from scratch using the new storage stack (a.k.a. storage-ng). And although this new Expert Partitioner already offers practically all the same features than the old one, some last options are still coming. One them in the button for moving partitions, which saves us of a lot unnecessary work in many cases. For example, imagine you are installing openSUSE Tumbleweed and the installer automatically proposes you to create a partition for root and, just following it, a second partition for home. In case you don’t like the default proposed sizes (e.g. because you want a bigger root), you have to use the Expert Partitioner to fix the situation. You have to completely remove the home partition, resize root for enlarging it and then create home again with the same options than before.

Now, with the “Move” button, this kind of modifications are much easier. For that example, you can accomplish exactly the same by simply resizing home (without deleting it completely) and moving the resized home closer to the end of the disk (by using Move button). After moving the home partition, you have enough free space for enlarging the root partition. In the following screenshot you can see this dialog for moving partitions.

Moving partitions

One important thing to take into account is that the movement of partitions is only possible for new partitions, that is, it is not possible to move partitions that already exist on disk.

Trying to move an existing partition

YaST Masking Systemd Mount and Swap Units

And speaking about the Partitioner and its relationship with the rest of the system, the transition from SysVinit to Systemd changed the behavior of (open)SUSE concerning mounting devices. Systemd generates mount units for various file systems, e.g. those listed in /etc/fstab. The result is that Systemd may automatically mount any file system, even if that file system has been manually unmounted before. This can be problematic when the user needs the file system to be unmounted for certain operations, like resizing or unplugging.

Thus, now the Partitioner uses a new mechanism to prevent that to happen during its execution. Starting with version 4.0.194, the yast2-storage-ng package includes and uses the script /usr/lib/YaST2/bin/mask-systemd-units to mask all mount and swap units one by one. The script might also be useful for direct use of system administrators. So… profit!

Showing Logs the Systemd Way

And since we speak about how Systemd has changed the way the overall system works, it’s also worth noticing how more and more services has been adopting the Systemd journal for its logging purposes.

Some of the existing YaST modules to configure a given service include a button to show the logs of such service. In the past, they used to display the content of /var/log/messages with some basic filtering to ensure only the information relative to the service (e.g. tftp) was shown. But that didn’t work out of the box for services already using the Systemd journal, and we had gotten quite some bug reports about it.

Fortunately, the solution is really at our fingertips. You surely know by now that there is a YaST module for viewing the journal content with powerful queries for filtering, searching and so so on. The obvious solution is to use that YaST journal module also within other YaST modules, in order to show domain specific logs.

So far we adapted the YaST tftp module, but it will be easy to fix also other places that use the old approach that no longer works. And this is how it looks when you click the “Show Logs” button in the YaST module to configure tftp.

Journal entries for the tftp module

Usability Improvement in the Repositories Manager

The YaST repositories manager displays the repositories sorted by priority. But some people have a lot of repositories in their system and make no use of the priorities. Since there was not a clear second criteria, the order of the repository list looked quite arbitrary in those cases. Now all the repositories with the same priority are sorted by name, which makes more sense. See how it looked before the improvement.

List of repositories sorted only by priority

And compare to how it looks now.

List of repositories sorted by priority and name

Handling Inconsistent Boot Methods During Upgrade

We got a rather interesting amount of bug reports for openSUSE Leap 15.0 about collisions between the grub2 and grub2-efi bootloaders during the upgrade process. The root cause was that the installation medium used a different booting mode than the installed system being upgraded. For example, the installed system uses EFI boot but the upgrade is executed from a DVD booted via legacy mode (i.e. disabling EFI). In that case, the kernel running from the DVD does not expose some devices that are needed to write to the EFI boot manager. Moreover, it causes troubles to the updater itself, which does not expect this situation.

Looking at the majority of the bug reports, it is obvious that in most cases it happens by accident rather than the user consciously trying to mix both boot modes. So to improve the user experience we added a warning that will be displayed when this situation is detected, before starting the upgrade. That gives the user the possibility to fix the problem or to continue if the situation is really intentional.

Below you can see how it looks, both in graphical and text mode, in a patched openSUSE Leap 15.0 installation media, since the feature was developed too late to be included in the official installation images.

Graphical warning about inconsistent boot mode

Text-mode warning about inconsistent boot mode

What’s Next? Hack Week!

As commented at the beginning of the post, we have restarted the sprint-based work, although with a little twist to try out the squads approach. But before we come back to you to show the results of the first squad-based sprint, we have something else to do – Hack Week 17!.

Again it’s the time of the year for all SUSE Engineers (and any Open Source enthusiast willing to join) to innovate and learn new stuff. So please forgive us if we go too deep into playing and we are less responsive next week. See you again soon!